The Transformative Era of Program Administration: Growing in a Changing Market Environment

Over the past decade, the United States program administrator market has undergone remarkable growth. From $17.5 billion in premiums in 2010, it soared to $79.07 billion in 2022, a massive 352% increase, according to the recent report released by Target Markets Association (TMPAA).

This growth trajectory vastly outpaces the general commercial insurance market's advancement, signifying the strategic importance of program administration within the broader industry context. 

Former Zurich North American Executive and VIPR Solutions US Advisor Greg Massey says the development reflects the growing significance of the program administrator sector within the broader insurance market. “The growth we’ve seen in program administration isn't merely a question of numbers,” he says. “It’s a reflection of a deeper evolution within the insurance market, where program administrators are forging new partnerships with their capacity providers to serve their customers.”

Navigating Through Change

What has driven this re-articulation of relationships in the sector? It is undoubtedly in part due to the need for collaboration between carriers and program administrators. “Insurers must align on long-term relationship management in the sector” says Tony Buckle, partner at UWX, the boutique insurance consultancy and former Chief Underwriting Officer at Allianz Global Corporate and Specialty. “So insurers are emphasising sustainability. They want to partner with administrators who have the specialist knowledge to build deep, enduring relationships with their end clients”

Administrators and carriers navigated through rate increases across various business lines, a trend reflective of developments in the broader commercial property and casualty insurance sector. “In facing challenging results compounded by the global pandemic, the sector had to demonstrate remarkable robustness. It was not just about weathering the storm; it was about emerging stronger, showcasing both to clients and carriers the sector's ability to adapt and thrive even under adverse conditions,” Massey says.

Buckle agrees “Carriers became much more involved in the process. Their focus is on specialty expertise and proven operations. Program administrators have become even more diligent, a welcomed approach by all. Transparency between all parties has been key to building trust.” 

Technological innovation within program administration has been a critical driving force. The increasing integration of data analytics and machine learning, particularly in underwriting and claims processing, has heralded a significant shift in operational strategies. “The technological transformation we’re witnessing is revolutionary,” explains Massey. “It is not just about adopting new tools; it is about a fundamental change in how we approach everything from risk assessment to customer engagement”. Buckle adds: Technology is more than an enabler - it is redefining the sector’s culture.”

Adapting to Changing Market Realities

Administrators and carriers have driven rate increases across various lines, echoing trends in the broader commercial P&C insurance market. “This resilience underlines the sector’s foundational strength and its ability to thrive under adverse conditions to improve operational efficiency,” Massey notes.

There was also further drop-off in the percentage of PAs using a Lloyd’s syndicate to support their program business, from 45 percent in 2020 to 39 percent – after declining from 58 percent between 2018 and 2020, according to the TMPAA report.

This trend, as Massey suggests, could be indicative of evolving perceptions of value and cost-effectiveness in placing business through Lloyd's, alongside a growing preference for local placements.

Another notable trend is the increased outsourcing of services such as data analytics and policy issuance, reflecting a shift towards more specialised operational models. "Outsourcing allows administrators to focus on their core competencies while leveraging external expertise for operational efficiency," explains Massey.

The Path Ahead

As we look to the future, the program administration market is poised for continued growth, underpinned by technological innovation and evolving market demands. “The future landscape of program administration is one where technology and data analytics will play a defining role. The ability to leverage these tools effectively will be the key to navigating the market's complexities and seizing opportunities,” predicts Massey. This technological shift is also reshaping the industry’s approach to emerging risks, such as cybersecurity and data protection. 

The increasing reliance on advanced technologies is expected to further refine operational processes, enhancing efficiency, addressing emerging risks and enriching customer experiences.

"Since 2009, VIPR's proficiency in bordereaux data management and analytics is a cornerstone in servicing the global delegated market," says Caroline Hanan, Chief Marketing Officer at VIPR Solutions. "Our focus is on providing cutting-edge solutions that empower program administrators and carriers to effectively manage and analyse their data in near real time. Our technology is designed to enhance operational efficiencies and provide deeper insights, enabling our customers to make informed decisions and stay ahead in a competitive environment. We are committed to innovation and excellence, ensuring that our customers are well-equipped to navigate the complexities of the program business industry and capitalise on growth opportunities."

Buckle adds “over the past couple of years, rising rates have boosted administrators and carriers alike, particularly in specialty insurance. The big question is what will happen when rates across the market start to fall, as they already are in management liability. It will be the administrators with the most trusted relationships with their carriers – where they are managing the portfolio dynamically and in partnership – that will emerge stronger and endeavour to improve the loss ratio”.

In conclusion, the program administrator market stands at a crossroads of opportunity and challenge. With a past marked by significant growth and a future ripe with potential, the sector is striving to continue its trajectory of innovation and strategic evolution. The journey from 2010 to 2022 has been nothing short of remarkable, with program administrators experiencing an exponential rise in premiums, a testament to their growing importance in the broader insurance landscape.

The sector's ability to adapt to changing market dynamics is a central narrative. Whether navigating the challenges of the pandemic or adjusting to the fluctuations in carrier relationships, particularly with the evolving use of Lloyd's syndicates, program administrators have shown resilience and adaptability. This adaptability is further underscored by the increasing trend towards outsourcing services like data analytics and policy issuance, allowing for a focus on core competencies while leveraging external expertise.

At the heart of this evolution lies technological innovation. The rise of data analytics and machine learning is not just reshaping operational strategies but is fundamentally altering the approach to risk management and customer engagement.

As the industry looks towards the future, with talented underwriters from general insurance companies making the move to delegated authority, this has been a driver of growth in the United States. In the recent TMPAA study, a staggering 83% of Program Administrators polled said they plan to introduce new programs in the next two years, while 96% of carriers said they plan to add new programs in the next three years. It’s certainly an area of focus and extreme growth and aided with smart tech and best-in-class analytics solutions, like VIPR’s, reducing loss ratio will be a priority for many.

Want to hear how TMPAA Members are leveraging VIPR's technology for their Delegated Data Management? BOOK A DEMO.